Showing posts with label argentine tango. Show all posts
Showing posts with label argentine tango. Show all posts

Thursday, July 25, 2013

Why I hate it when you say "it's always the leader's fault"

When a misstep occurs in Argentine tango (and, I imagine, in other social dances), regardless of how it occurs, it's become commonplace for the man to take responsibility by saying "it's always the leader's fault." Even though I understand that leaders have only the most gracious and gentlemanly intentions when they say this, every time a man says this to me while we're dancing, I can feel the hairs on the back of my neck stand up.

As a follower, I have spent six years searching for the place on my partner's back that will produce the greatest amount of mutual comfort and communication when I rest my hand there. Searching for the place on the floor that matches the size of the step he's proposing, and the part of my foot that will create stability for me and transparency for him when I move onto it. For the position of my spine that will allow me to remain present and alive to his intentions without burdening him with the weight of my upper body. For a way to salute my favorite moment in that magical tango by Canaro when the bandoneón says this and the piano answers that - but without derailing the intentions of my partner - and for the stillness of mind that awakens me to the spontaneous possibility of each moment, never presuming to know what my partner will ask of me, but trusting that it will move me through and through.

Six years in, I am still searching. And if you think nothing ever goes wrong with that endeavor, you're crazy.

If the message a leader sends is murky, lacks confidence, or contradicts itself, then certainly he's at fault: if you don't lead it, I can't follow it. Leaders are also responsible for gauging the level of skill of their partners. If you take a follower into territory that she obviously lacks the skill level to navigate, then you are to blame when she doesn't respond as you had hoped. But to say that "it's always the leader's fault" is to undermine the importance and sophistication of the follower's task.

I know you don't mean to, but when you say "it's always the leader's fault", you underestimate my potential to detract from the dance - and, by extension, my potential to add to it. In essence you're implying that what I do doesn't matter, which renders me irrelevant, just a hapless, passive vessel for your intentions rather than a co-creator of our shared experience on the dance floor.

Moreover, it's disingenuous. We've all led the Compulsive Ocho-er, the Great Anticipator, and the follower who is so much the master of her fate, the captain of her soul, that - try as we might - we cannot settle her down into the state of interdependence that the dance thrives on. Surely at some point, it's reasonable to expect her to assume some responsibility. As we say in the States, "it takes two to tango". Convincing ourselves that it's always the leader's fault has the potential to breed lazy, entitled followers, and who wants to dance with one of those?

At the risk of reading too much into this whole thing, I think it stems from the relative value that society assigns to speaking and listening. We tend to associate action and subjecthood with the act of speaking or sending a message; inaction and objecthood to the act of listening or receiving a message. In fact, in life just as in tango, the art of active listening is extraordinarily challenging. It's a skill that tango followers must master early on, and in my experience the best leaders are the ones who cultivate it as well.

So, leaders, the next time you feel tempted to take responsibility for a follower's error, instead take her at her word that she did something she wishes she had danced differently. Engage her as an equal partner with strengths, aspirations and vulnerabilities worthy of your respect and recognition. You'll both be the better for it.






Monday, April 23, 2012

owning tango

I don't think I write enough about tango.  Anyone who doesn't dance it and has been reading this might disagree with me, but if you really look at the proportion of my time I spend dancing tango, thinking about tango, talking about tango, listening to the music, it would be clear to you that I spend a disproportionately weensy amount of time writing about it as opposed to about other things.

Thing is, I think I may have had a bit of an epiphany this weekend with respect to my dance (which inevitably translates into an epiphany about my self - or at least I can imagine it does).  Despite having danced tango for about 6 years on and off (luckily, more on than off), I don't think I have ever thought of myself as a "tango dancer".  Tango dancers have always been my teachers, or the people who come in to teach me and my teachers, or the graceful, willowy people I see at milongas in Washington, D.C. or New York or elsewhere.   I think I've always perceived myself as an interloper, someone who hasn't been at it long enough to assert my interpretation of the music or call myself "good" enough to not have something to prove.

I'm an innate teacher; it's something that I do without even meaning to and in fact, articulating my experience of things to someone else helps the lessons imprint upon me.  So, if it's in the context of learning among my peers or with those who have less experience than I do, I'm all confidence and certainty.  Get me into a social setting where the dancers are truly good, though, and suddenly I'm a clutching, cowering ball of nerves whose walk and embrace say  "did I get it right?  Is this what you wanted?  How am I doing?  How about now?"

I mean, I danced for four years before I finally allowed myself to buy a pair of regulation tango shoes.  I felt like I had to earn them somehow, to graduate to those stilettos.  They are the most beautiful thing, by the way.  If a fire burns our house down, I will save them after the dog but before my wedding dress.  But I held that door closed to myself until I managed to meet some unspecified, murky criteria that I alone invented.

Since then, I have written about and sung the music, DJ'ed events, danced successfully with strangers far from my own cozy little community (always a big test), met some of the people in those YouTube videos and found them human, I even started learning the leader's role... yet I still somehow haven't thought of myself as an insider.  Just because I dance tango three nights a week and think about it constantly and try to get everyone in my life to do it, just because it's become my pet metaphor for life, the universe and everything, doesn't mean I think I'm any good at it or have any claim to it.  Yet I don't begrudge anyone else that ownership and pole star of identification regardless of their level of expertise.  My criteria for belonging applies uniquely but unappealably to me and me alone.

After a private lesson with teachers I respect, I now think this is a big part of what's holding my dance back.  The next frontier of learning for me is to dance without apology, but with every ounce of joy it gives me.  To turn off the perpetual evaluation machine in my head and just be present to my partner inside the music.
To concern myself less with doing exactly what's expected of me, and to be more open to the possibilities that are offered to me...then, to go boldly forward (or backward, or sideways, or around, depending), because this space is mine to claim.

Uh-oh.  This is almost certainly telling me something about my life.


Wednesday, June 15, 2011

tangovangelism

I have been fairly restrained on this subject, considering how much of my life is taken up by this activity, but I am happy to say that as of today the hubs and I have successfully tango-vangelized five people and continue to bring the good word to anyone who demonstrates so much as a passing curiosity in our argentine tango obsession, which has been going strong for five years now and shows no signs of abating. That's one convert per year since we started, and they're all still practicing believers...I wonder how we stack up against Mormons or Seventh Day Adventists. Maybe we should try hanging out at the airport, or on busy corners in Third World countries.

Tonight we have class and tomorrow, [info]jkgeroo welcomes us into her home to try to bring her honey-love into the light. I'm a bit nervous because I know what an enraptured crank I become when I get started on tango. Tango is yoga for two, the secret to tango is the same as the secret to a healthy relationship, tango is zen, approach tango the way you would a road trip, insert metaphor of choice.

Dancing tango has changed my musical tastes, my fashion sense, my body image. It's changed how I approach conflict resolution, physical activity, and teaching and learning. It's helped me push my own limits and live in the moment (it's also given me a rock-hard spot on the outer edge of each big toe that I am pretty sure will never go away).

I'm beginning to think that there is a difference between broad pursuits and deep pursuits. Broad pursuits are those that, by nature, call for people to acquire ever greater quantities of skills, techniques, facts or things: like stamp collecting or baseball statistics or trivia night. Deep pursuits are the kind that, by nature, call for you to do the same handful of things better and better as you go, like yoga. You can bring a deep or broad approach to deep or broad pursuits, but if you bring a deep approach to stamp collecting you'll hit bottom fairly quickly, and if you bring a broad approach to yoga you'll soon wonder what the big deal about yoga is. Finding enduring satisfaction in either kind of activity calls for bringing the adequate approach to it. Some people get easily bored with deep pursuits because they need immediate payoffs - the progress in deep pursuits is often glacial and cyclical. I'm more prone to boredom with broad pursuits, because I can foresee myself eventually exhausting them without really having to interrogate anything within myself.

I'm sure you can see where this is going...I think Argentine tango is a deep pursuit. People who approach it as a broad pursuit are interlopers looking to add to their repertoire, or the chronic gancho-ers and boleo-ers (ganchos and boleos are those fancy leg hooks and flourishes you see on Dancing With the Stars) that clog up the dance floor and stiletto people in the shins. Once they've punched themselves out, they'll move on to another broad pursuit. To the uninitiated eye, tango approached deeply can look almost boring. But I can promise you: the less you see, the more is happening for the two people in the embrace.

Now that I've fallen this deep into my chosen pursuit, it's hard for me to imagine anyone not wanting to dance tango, or for that matter dabbling in it. I guess I think a satisfying life requires at least one deep pursuit approached deeply. What's yours

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

tangomania strikes at will

It appears that, for the first time in my life, I have a hobby. In the sense that for the first time in my life I have an activity I'm willing to burn time, money, and fossil fuels in order to learn to do it better, for the sincere enjoyment of it. This is an activity that has little practical application in the rest of my life. I will never do it professionally, and yet I have a strong and specific desire for improvement in regard to it.

What is it that makes tango so addictive? I think, for one thing, tango just f e e l s really, really good. When you're doing it right, you get a delicious stretch through your back muscles, like that first-stretch-of-the-morning kind of stretch. In fact, tango seems to share (inadvertently) a lot with practices like yoga and tai chi -- at least to my rudimentary understanding. Like yoga, every movement in tango is counterbalanced by a movement in the opposite direction: at once upward and lifted, downward and grounded. Like tai chi, it hinges on balance and the transferrence of energy from one part of the body to another, or even between one body and another. It seems only fitting that the Latino-Parisian version of these activities -- intended to wholly experience ourselves mentally, spiritually and physically -- requires both a man and a woman.

For another thing, consider the shoes. This is the only dance -- nay, human activity -- that can actually be performed better in four-inch heels. Seriously. We're talking about the kind of shoes that Sarah Jessica Parker would give her skinny little right arm for, okay? Hand-made in Buenos Aires (probably by tiny hands, but I'd prefer to think by a tragic tanguera injured in some dramatic dancefloor incident who personally sniffs every shoe for optimal performance), these babies have leather souls. Not long ago, this dancin' fool and her money narrowly escaped being parted, the objet de désir being a pair of ballet-slipper-pink and silver spectator shoes with a rhinestone buckle and chrome (yes, chrome!) stiletto heels. The neighbs tore me away the moment he saw I showed promising signs of coming to my senses. Alas.

But I think what I love most about tango is the way it engages my mind as much as my body. Sorry to disappoint all the ballroom fans out there with their five-step pattern (T! A! N-G-O!), but social Argentine tango has no basic step. You could go in any direction at any time, or go nowhere at all for several consecutive beats. This means that leaders have to demonstrate superior navigational skills on the dancefloor and communicate unwavering intentionality to their followers. In turn, followers have to be constantly attentive and receptive, never anticipating what might be asked of them, but ready to go wherever, whenever. In return for this submissiveness, the leader creates opportunities for his follower to show her creativity by embellishing and occasionally taking as long as she damn well pleases to execute what he's asking her to do.

If I were to describe swing-dancing in one word, it would be "flirtation". Salsa might be "sex", but tango, without a doubt, would be "love". Each partner must be perpetually on his/her own two feet, so that if the other stepped away s/he would still be standing, but in order to go anywhere the communication between them must be absolute, and both parties must listen intently to one another. Even though it's touted as an extremely sexy dance, even at its most aggressive or dramatic, there's a tenderness and restraint to tango that doesn't exist in other dances.

So there you have it. Wanna dance yet?